Kate S WHITBURN nee CATER 1879 -1961 (General)
Thank you slowhands,
I have all that data but the 1881 census info is for one person and the rest is for the Kate born in Monmouth Workhouse in 1886.
The only thing I can think happened is between the GRO registration and the baptism is William and Mary Ann Cater had a change of mind about their daughter's names; changing it from Mary Ann J to Kate Sophia.