I have this family as several of the children married Colwells (my paternal line). I can't guarantee the following as I didn't take it very far, but it would be worth your checking out a son Thomas b.1825 who married Elizabeth Colwell in 1851, and Harriett b.c1832 who married Charles Coldrick in 1851. Mary married Robert Colwell in 1852. Judith died in 1870 bd. Newent. Do let me know if you find these extra children of Judith match the family as I did this search some years ago and there is more evidence available now.

Thomas Davis (dates unknown) and Judith Sullivan 1797-1880 baptized a number of children.
Those that I have are:-
Elizabeth bap 1 Jun 1817 Aston Ingham.
Anne 4 Apr 1819 Aston Ingham.
Maryanne 24 May 1824 Aston Ingham.
Caroline 9 Jul 1829 Aston Ingham.
All are in records on this site.
In 1829 at the Lent Assizes at Gloucester Thomas was found guilty of house breaking and sentence to death, which was commuted to transportation for life.
Judith then lived with Benjamin Paine and had children with him, again baptismal record are on this site, eventually marrying him 2 Mar 1848 Aston Ingham. The marriage record on this site gives Judith's father as Joseph Sullivan.
I have not been able to find a marriage for Thomas Davis and Judith Sullivan and would like to ask if anyone has any details of their marriage.
Many thanks.

Name:Judith Payne
Estimated Birth Year:abt 1790
Date of Registration:Jul-Aug-Sep 1870
Age at Death:80
Registration District:Newent
Inferred County:Gloucestershire
Volume:6a
Page:199

Year: 1870
Month: Sep
Day: 20
Surname: PAYNE
Forenames: Judith
Residence: Mesne Newent
Age_at_death: 81
Officiating_Minister: H[enr]y L. Whatley
Event: Burial
Cause_of_death:
Memoranda:
Notes:
Register_Reference: AR90/10
Page_No: 88
Parish_Chapel: Aston Ingham

1861
Benjamin Paine abt 1799 Oxenhall, Gloucestershire, England Head Newent, Gloucestershire
Judith Paine abt 1793 Ireland Wife Newent, Gloucestershire
Caroline Davis abt 1829 Aston Ingham, Herefordshire, England Daughter-in-law Newent, Gloucestershire
Ann Coldrick abt 1855 Newent, Gloucestershire, England Granddaughter Newent, Gloucestershire

1851
Benjamin Paine abt 1801 Oxenhall, Gloucestershire, England Head Newent, Gloucestershire
Judith Paine abt 1797 Ireland Wife Newent, Gloucestershire
Caroline Davis abt 1830 Aston Ingham, Herefordshire, England Daughter Newent, Gloucestershire
Benjamin Pain abt 1835 Aston Ingham, Herefordshire, England Son Newent, Gloucestershire
Salina Pain abt 1844 Newent, Gloucestershire, England Daughter Newent, Gloucestershire
Eliza Pain abt 1843 Newent, Gloucestershire, England Daughter Newent, Gloucestershire

--
Ἀριστοτέλης A Gloster Boy in the Forest of Dean ><((((*>

Is this the same Thomas DAVIS?

Gloucestershire Genealogical Database : Thomas DAVIS was aged 41 in 1828 c 1787

Year: 1828

Surname: DAVIS

Public Address: Aston Ingham Herefordshire

Occupation: labourer

Forename: Thomas

Date of Committal - 14 May 1828

Reference: W/Gc5/3

---

Ancestry:

Thomas DAVIS, July 1828, Larcency - Not Guilty

---

On the records the name SULLIVAN has a number of Hawker's as occupation.