too many Thomas BARNARDs with wife Mary.... and a Mary GOODE (General)

by macast , North Yorkshire, England, Sunday, November 09, 2014, 12:36 (3661 days ago)

could anyone PLEASE help me sort out a mess?

I have 2 Richard BARNARDs living close by in 1871 census for East Dean (below).
Richard No.1 is the line I have been most interested in as Alfred BARNARD (his son) is the correct great grandfather of my partner's line.
Richard No.1 is the son of Thomas BARNARD (1) and Lucy HARRIS
Richard No.2 is the son of Thomas BARNARD (2) and Mary _?_
Thomas BARNARD No.1 is the son of Thomas BARNARD and Mary
but Richard BARNARD No.2 is also the son of a Thomas BARNARD and Mary
one of the Thomas' married Mary GOODE (below)

can anyone understand where I am..... and please help me sort out who belongs where?

1)Richard
1871 census East Dean, Cinderford
Richard Barnard Head - Male 36 1835 - Gloucestershire, England
Elizabeth Barnard Wife - Female 36 1835 - Gloucestershire, England
William Barnard Son - Male 11 1860 - Gloucestershire, England
Emily Sophia Barnard Daughter - Female 9 1862 - Gloucestershire, England
Oliver Jno Barnard Son - Male 7 1864 - Gloucestershire, England
Alfred Barnard Son - Male 5 1866 - Gloucestershire, England
Moses Barnard Son - Male 4 1867 - Gloucestershire, England
Eli Barnard Son - Male 0 1870 (11months)
Archive reference RG10 Piece number 2599 Folio 20 Page 32 Record set 1871 England, Wales & Scotland Census

2)Richard
1871 census for East Dean, Cinderford
Richard Barnard Head - Male 50 1821 - Gloucestershire, England
Mary Barnard Wife - Female 51 1820 - Gloucestershire, England
Michel Barnard Son - Male 17 1854 - Gloucestershire, England
Emily Elizabth Barnard Daughter - Female 8 1863 - Gloucestershire, England
Street Cinderford Parish East Dean Town - City - County Gloucestershire Country England Registration district Westbury on Severn Archive reference RG10 Piece number 2599 Folio 21 Page 33 Record set 1871 England, Wales & Scotland Census

Thomas No.1 baptism
Record_ID: 414539 Entry_Number: Year: 1799 Month: Jun Day: 30 Parents_Surname: BARNARD Child_Forenames: Thomas Fathers_Forenames: Thomas Mothers_Forenames: Mary Mothers_Surname: Residence: Occupation: Officiating_Minister: Event: Baptism Memoranda: Son of Notes: Father's name Thos entered in the PR has been expanded to Thomas Register_Reference: P220 IN 1/2 Page_Number: 21 Parish_Chapel: Mitcheldean Soundex: B656

Richard No.2 baptism
Record_ID: 120 Entry_Number: 119 Year: 1821 Month: Mar Day: 12 Parents_Surname: BARNARD Child_Forenames: Richard Fathers_Forenames: Thomas Mothers_Forenames: Mary Mothers_Surname: Residence: Forest Occupation: Labourer Officiating_Minister: John Newport Event: Baptism Memoranda: Notes: Any abbreviated forenames have been expanded to the full name Register_Reference: P1 IN 1/7 Page_Number: 15 Parish_Chapel: Abenhall Soundex: B656

marriage of Thomas BARNARD and Mary GOODE
Record_ID: 32321 Entry_Number: 17 Year: 1799 Month: Feb Day: 17 Grooms_Surname: BARNARD Grooms_Forenames: Thomas Grooms_Age: Groom_Condition: Grooms_Occupation: Grooms_Residence: Abenhall Grooms_Fathers_Surname: Grooms_Fathers_Forenames: Grooms_Fathers_Occupation: Brides_Surname: GOODE Brides_Forenames: Mary Brides_Age: Brides_Condition: Brides_Occupation: Brides_Residence: Abenhall Brides_Fathers_Surname: Brides_Fathers_Forenames: Brides_Fathers_Occupation: Licence_or_Banns: Banns Date_of_Banns: Signature_or_Mark: Both mark Witness_1: Mark of Thomas Plasted Witness_2: Richd Lowe Other_Witnesses: Officiating_Minister: John Probyn Event: Marriage Memoranda: Notes: Not in BTs Register_Reference: P1 IN 1/5 Page_Number: 11 Parish_Chapel: Abenhall Soundex_Groom: B656 Soundex_Bride: G300