Alice Ann TAYLOR (birth 1890 or 1891) (General)
I wonder if anyone could check the parish register for the West Dean Methodist Church - register reference D2598/3/5 page 8.
The transcript on this excellent web site has the Baptism as 25 January 1890 but the only birth index is Q1; 1891; Monmouth. I know that sometimes birth registrations are delayed, but I wouldn't have thought that it would be for 1 year. So I wondered if the year had been transcribed incorrectly.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Alice Ann TAYLOR (birth 1890 or 1891) Lydbrook
by slowhands 
, proud of his ancient Dean Forest roots, Tuesday, January 05, 2010, 18:36 (5511 days ago) @ vblease
If we assume the transcribed records go in sequence then I agree Alice Ann was probably born late in 1890, perhaps December rather than January 1890 , and then the 25th is now out of sequence ! The image needs checking to see if its a transcription error or as recorded in the register.
Record ID 173085
Entry Number 60
Year 1890
Month Jul
Day 20
Parents Surname BARNETT
Child Forenames Gladys Eleanor
Fathers Forenames Edwin
Mothers Forenames Charlett[sic] Eleanor
Mothers Surname
Residence Lydbrook
Occupation Labourer
Officiating Minister Wm Starling
Event Baptism
Memoranda
Notes
Register Reference D2598/3/5
Page Number 8
Parish Chapel West Dean Methodist
Name: Gladys Eleanor Barnett
Year of Registration: 1890
Quarter of Registration: Jul-Aug-Sep
District: Monmouth (1837-1939)
County: Gloucestershire, Herefordshire, Monmouthshire
Volume: 11a
Page: 20
Record ID 173086
Entry Number 61
Year 1890
Month Jan
Day 25
Parents Surname TAYLOR
Child Forenames Alice Ann
Fathers Forenames Alfred
Mothers Forenames Elizabeth
Mothers Surname
Residence Lydbrook
Occupation Tinman
Officiating Minister A. Chandler
Event Baptism
Memoranda
Notes
Register Reference D2598/3/5
Page Number 8
Parish Chapel West Dean Methodist
Name: Alice Ann Taylor
Year of Registration: 1891
Quarter of Registration: Jan-Feb-Mar
District: Monmouth (1837-1939)
County: Gloucestershire, Herefordshire, Monmouthshire
Volume: 11a
Page: 26
Record ID 173087
Entry Number 62
Year 1890
Month Dec
Day 17
Parents Surname PARTRIDGE
Child Forenames Ellin Ethal
Fathers Forenames Isaiah
Mothers Forenames Lucsia
Mothers Surname
Residence Lydbrook
Occupation Collier
Officiating Minister J.Jones
Event Baptism
Memoranda
Notes
Register Reference D2598/3/5
Page Number 8
Parish Chapel West Dean Methodist
Name: Ellen Ethel Partridge
Year of Registration: 1891
Quarter of Registration: Jan-Feb-Mar
District: Westbury On Severn
County: Gloucestershire
Volume: 6a
Page: 252
--
Ἀριστοτέλης A Gloster & Hereford Boy in the Forest of Dean ><((((*>
Alice Ann TAYLOR (birth 1890 or 1891) Lydbrook
by grahamdavison , Tuesday, January 05, 2010, 22:18 (5511 days ago) @ slowhands
I have just checked the original entry which is definitely entered as 25 Jan 1890 however as Slowhands points out the preceeding entry is 20 July 1890 and the following entry 17 Dec 1890, so there is probably a mistake in the register and the year should be 1891.
Possible transcription errors
by admin 
, Forest of Dean, Wednesday, January 06, 2010, 01:03 (5511 days ago) @ vblease
I wonder if anyone could check the parish register for the West Dean Methodist Church - register reference D2598/3/5 page 8.
We have a system in place for checking any possible transcription errors.
Please read
Possible Transcription Errors section on our Parish Records page.
http://www.forum.forest-of-dean.net/index.php?mode=page&id=1
Possible transcription errors
Have now submitted a transcription check. Thanks for telling me about your process.
Val
Transcript I think is correct
by admin , Forest of Dean, Wednesday, January 06, 2010, 16:59 (5510 days ago) @ vblease
Thanks for submitting the request which I have just answered but for the benefit of others I have copied my reply below.
I don't think you will ever be able to confirm the correct date of birth or baptisms for certain as things just were not all that accurate in those days and often incorrect dates were recorded in documents because it was convenient to do so.
---
I will consult with Graham on this one but I believe the entry we have as being stated as 1890 is correct.
I do not have copies of the originals to look at but I do have the transcripts and looking through them I noticed that the dates are generally not in order.
These are circuit records and what I think has happened is that the baptisms were preformed in different locations and then later the details were entered into a Register that was probably kept at a central location. The details arriving possibly months later in some cases at the central location from other places and this is the reason for them not being in date order.
Transcript may be correct but register wrong.
by shepway , Wednesday, January 06, 2010, 22:21 (5510 days ago) @ admin
I have checked the 1891 Census entry and Alice is stated to be 3 months old. The 1891 Census took place on 5 April and 25 January 1891 was a Sunday. I would therefore suggest that the baptism took place in 1891.
Mike
Note added to the record
by admin , Forest of Dean, Thursday, January 07, 2010, 01:20 (5510 days ago) @ shepway
It appears from other records of the person that the year of the event is 1891. It would however be wrong for us to change the year that has been recorded in the register as we do a true transcript of the records and do not enter in our transcripts what we believe it should be in place of what has been written in the original record.
I've added the following note to the record which is in our website database.
"Other records indicate that the year of the event is 1891"