Thank you very much Slowhands for all of this! :)

I knew Phoebe was with Benjamin in 1861 but hadn't worked out the relationship. Could he be her son given that she would have been about 18 when he was born? There is no relationship on the census image.

Also, why does the parish record say Benjamin Barnett and the IGI say Benjamin Barnett Marshall. Barnett/Barnes is coincidental isn't it?

Simone x