Yes, I'm a born and bred Forester.

Anyway, moving on, I hope you don't mind but as an experiment I've been trying to assess how the FindMyPast site compares with Ancestry etc, and I thought I'd try and find your Hannah Marina Drew and maybe her parents Joseph Drew and Eleanor Niblett in the 1841 Census, a task I thought might be straightforward, however !..

Meanwhile, in the unlikely case it helps you, I did find these records which you haven't yet posted onto your tree.

From this site's PRs, image is now on Ancestry,

Record_ID: 16917
Entry_Number: 60
Year: 1825
Month: Feb
Day: 5
Grooms_Surname: DREWE
Grooms_Forenames: Joseph
Grooms_Age:
Groom_Condition: [not stated]
Grooms_Occupation:
Grooms_Residence: of this parish
Grooms_Fathers_Surname:
Grooms_Fathers_Forenames:
Grooms_Fathers_Occupation:
Brides_Surname: NIBLETT
Brides_Forenames: Eleanor
Brides_Age:
Brides_Condition: [not stated]
Brides_Occupation:
Brides_Residence: of this parish
Brides_Fathers_Surname:
Brides_Fathers_Forenames:
Brides_Fathers_Occupation:
Licence_or_Banns: Banns
Date_of_Banns:
Signature_or_Mark: Both mark
Witness_1: Mark of John Niblett
Witness_2: Mark of Sarah Drewe
Other_Witnesses:
Officiating_Minister: Richard Davies Rector
Event: Marriage
Memoranda:
Notes:
Register_Reference: P310 IN 1/9
Page_Number: 20
Parish_Chapel: Staunton
Soundex_Groom: D600
Soundex_Bride: N143

This suggests that witness John Niblett MAY be Eleanor's father's name. This suggests the following Baptism may be relevant, from this site's PRs albeit needed to use the Advanced Search for all Baptisms c1803 surname starting "Nib". Odd as I was expecting the Eleanor to have maybe become Helena etc as we often see in the Fod.

Hope this helps, does Hewelsfield seem possible, perhaps they travelled north from there up the Wye to reach Staunton ?.

Record_ID 288762
Entry_Number
Year 1803
Month May
Day 22
Parents_Surname NIBLET
Child_Forenames Elinor
Fathers_Forenames John
Mothers_Forenames Margaret
Mothers_Surname
Residence
Occupation
Officiating_Minister Thomas Edmunds Curate
Event Baptism
Memoranda
Notes
Register_Reference P175 IN 1/2
Page_Number 34
Parish_Chapel Hewelsfield
Soundex N143

Re my "trial" of the FMP site, I must say I'm disappointed so far, but early days yet....

---------------

PS ref the possible Hewelsfield link, I now see that by searching this forum for "Niblett Hewelsfield" there are a few prior threads linking Hewelsfield to the Staunton/Bicknor etc area, these may be worth your studying.

PPS And while Googling the above, I see this Ancestry Board post that appears to back-up my findings re Eleanor, and maybe some new living relatives for you to chat with ?
http://boards.ancestry.ca/thread.aspx?mv=flat&m=76&p=surnames.niblett

This is why I like the FamilySearch website, I often use it before I use Ancestry, as it gives quicker results and is more user-friendly than many of the "bigger" sites, especially as it automatically offers spelling variations. Ancestry's beginning to annoy me nowadays as it continues to gives umpteen "hits" for, say Marriages, when I've already found and saved into my trees the one that obviously matches my search criteria, whereas the suggestions so often clearly NOT relevant at all. Hence my disappointment when FindMyPast offered me so little ...
In fact to be honest I didn't realise the Baptisms I'd posted in my reply were Robertsons and not your Robinsons until some while after I'd cut & pasted them, hence lots of "rambling" backtracking in the rest of my post as I tried to convince myself I was on the right track, it was the Marriage for Selina that seemed to clinch it.

Ref the online tree I found, some of the birthplaces Selina appears to quote in the Census' look very odd eg Frampton-o-Severn, hence I "forgot" to mention those...
I'm sure you'll make sense of them all.

I'll check through all the info over the next couple of days but it all looks to make sense.

The Ancestry tree you found wasn't mine. Mine's at http://person.ancestry.co.uk/tree/54239731/person/13720257559/facts

Anne ROBERTSON 21 May 1837 at Longhope, parents: Thomas (labourer) & Amy

?

Family Search

1841 Census Longhope

ROBERTSON

Thomas - 45-49 (all born Gloucestershire)
Ann - 40-44
Charlotte - 15-19
Charles - 12
Henry - 10
Hannah - 8
Ann - 4

---

?

Marriage At Cinderford St John - 21 May 1865

Hannah Eliza ROBINSON - aged 30 residence: East Dean
father: Thomas ROBINSON - labourer

married

James SMITH - Bachelor, Groom and Gardener, residence: East Dean
father: John SMITH, labourer

witnesses: William PRICE and Selina PRICE

---

William PRICE married Selina ROBINSON (father Thomas) at Cinderford St John - 30 December 1860
witnesses: Thomas MEREDITH and Hannah ROBINSON.

Amy ROBINSON aged 79 (c1798) of Harry Hill, buried at Drybrook - 5 January 1877

1871 Censis
Abinghall

ROBINSON

William - 54 - born Abenhall
Amy ROBINSON - mother - 74 - born Tainton
Sarah Ann - daughter - 22 - born Abenhall
Thomas ROBINSON - nephew - 3 born Abenhall
Ann Amelia ROBINSON - niece - 2 - born Abenhall

The variations in quoted birthplaces makes sense to me.
I've known of Longhope as a placename since my youth in the 70s, yet was only a few years ago via this hobby & this website that I learnt of a smaller village nearby called Taynton. It seems logical that some census officials would maybe write "Longhope" if told someone was from "Taynton, near Longhope", for example. Similarly seems reasonable for a census official in Lydbrook to write Mitcheldean instead of, say, Longhope.

LDS aka FamilySearch website has this Baptism which looks a possible fit; admittedly a subtly different surname but worth considering, I'm told FamilySearch are renowned for transcription errors, and sometimes church ministers mishear ?.

Name George Robertson
Gender Male
Christening Date 21 May 1826
Christening Place TAYNTON,GLOUCESTER,ENGLAND
Father's Name Thomas Robertson
Mother's Name Amy

https://familysearch.org/search/record/results?count=20&query=%2Bgivenname%3Ageorge...

HOWEVER, I now see (via Ancestry) that the original Parish Record for this Baptism does clearly state ROBERTSON, but the only George ROBERTson of this age/birthplace I can find living locally in 1841 & 1851 is in Gloucester with parents Samuel & Elizabeth, so maybe this IS our George's baptism record with an incorrect surname ?

My quick look on Ancestry and FamilySearch haven't found our George Robinson in 1841 either, just the later Census', but I'll keep looking. Disappointingly, my newfound access to the FindMyPast site isn't helping me at all, but that's probably me !

Back to FamilySearch, this time searching for Thomas & Amy in Taynton around 1825, gives this record which looks like a sister to George. Researching her may help build the full picture for George.

Name Selina Robertson
Gender Female
Christening Date 17 Aug 1823
Christening Place TAYNTON,GLOUCESTER,ENGLAND
Father's Name Thomas Robertson
Mother's Name Amy

FoD PRs have the full transcriptions for both these siblings;

Record_ID: 154934
Entry_Number: 148
Year: 1823
Month: Aug
Day: 17
Parents_Surname: ROBERTSON
Child_Forenames: Selina
Fathers_Forenames: Thomas
Mothers_Forenames: Amy
Mothers_Surname:
Residence: Aston Ingham Herefordshire
Occupation: Labourer
Officiating_Minister: W[illia]m Bushell
Event: Baptism
Memoranda:
Notes:
Register_Reference: P326 IN 1/5
Page_Number: 19
Parish_Chapel: Taynton
Soundex: R163

Record_ID: 154975
Entry_Number: 195
Year: 1826
Month: May
Day: 21
Parents_Surname: ROBERTSON
Child_Forenames: George
Fathers_Forenames: Thomas
Mothers_Forenames: Amy
Mothers_Surname:
Residence: Tainton
Occupation: Labourer
Officiating_Minister: W[illia]m Bushell
Event: Baptism
Memoranda:
Notes:
Register_Reference: P326 IN 1/5
Page_Number: 25
Parish_Chapel: Taynton
Soundex: R163

I've searched for a Marriage for Thomas & Amy Robinson, and Robertson, within the FoD site PRs, and also on Ancestry and FamilySearch, sadly wothout success. Ditto the 1841 & 1851 Census.

?????

Re the Robinson OR Robertson name question, I think it worth noting that I cannot find ANY Marriage Records for a Selina ROBERTSON on FreeBMD site in Gloucestershire or Herefordshire, yet there are some for Selina ROBINSONs. Similarly there are far more marriage records for George ROBINSONs compared to just a few for Robertson, who seem far less numerous in our area.

This one seems a good fit for our Selina born 1827, note father Thos and witness Hannah Robinson, who MAY be her sister-in-law, George married Hannah Drew in 1856.

Record_ID: 37356
Entry_Number: 337
Year: 1860
Month: Dec
Day: 30
Grooms_Surname: PRICE
Grooms_Forenames: William
Grooms_Age: 30
Groom_Condition: Bachelor
Grooms_Occupation: Collier
Grooms_Residence: East Dean
Grooms_Fathers_Surname: Price
Grooms_Fathers_Forenames: John
Grooms_Fathers_Occupation: Labourer
Brides_Surname: ROBINSON
Brides_Forenames: Selina
Brides_Age: 37
Brides_Condition: Spinster
Brides_Occupation:
Brides_Residence: East Dean
Brides_Fathers_Surname: Robinson
Brides_Fathers_Forenames: Tho[ma]s
Brides_Fathers_Occupation: Labourer
Licence_or_Banns: Banns
Date_of_Banns:
Signature_or_Mark: Both mark
Witness_1: Thomas Meredith
Witness_2: Mark of Hannah Robinson
Other_Witnesses:
Officiating_Minister: Tho[ma]s Gosselin Smythies
Event: Marriage
Memoranda:
Notes:
Register_Reference: P85/1 IN 1/4
Page_Number: 169
Parish_Chapel: Cinderford St John
Soundex_Groom: P620
Soundex_Bride: R152

Their 1861 & 1881 Census records in Drybrook (so near Mitcheldean etc) gives this Selina's birthplace in abt 1825 as Aston Ingham & Longhope respectively, as per the above Baptism Record.

????

-----------

Ancestry has one public family tree for the same George Robinson that you're researching, is it your tree ?. This apears thoroughly detailed/researched, but also doesn't have his 1841 Census details, nor his Baptism or parents' names. It shows him in Lydbrook in all the Census' from 1851 thro to 1891. However in 1892 his wife Hannah dies, in 1901 Census he's in Leigh, Lancashire with his married daughter Marina Key, it doesnt give his death date. Obviously I'm not saying to rely totally on any public tree, errors do occur, but it may be helpful.
http://trees.ancestry.co.uk/tree/48900887/family?cfpid=28115703584

If anyone has any information I'd be happy to receive it.

Thanks