Does our DNA come from our Ancestors (General)
by ritpetite , New Zealand, Monday, August 15, 2011, 22:19 (4852 days ago)
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors, in other words would we have a similar DNA to a distant cousin from the same grandparents as far back as Adam and Eve.
Sorry just wondered. The Forest of Dean is so different than anywhere else that we are all just one big family as far as I am concerned.
Rita
NZ
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by jhopkins , Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 10:49 (4852 days ago) @ ritpetite
Kia ora Rita
Perhaps you could have a look in your local library for books by Brian Sykes of Oxford University. They are a great read. His first in the series is Seven Daughters of Eve, wherein he traces mitochondrial DNA (the dna you get from your mum) back to seven hypothetical daughters of a hypothetical Eve. Mitochondrial DNA is very interesting because it is very slow to mutate, and because of the clarity of the record, he has been able to put people into seven broad families.
He did quite a bit of his original research when he was recovering from a motor bike accident in the hospital at Rarotonga - on Polynesian mitochondrial DNA because the hospital had lots of blood samples. A key result of his research has been to trace Māori origins back to Taiwan - thus confirming the navigational, archaeological, and linguistic record, so that part is of interest to us in our wee corner of the world.
There are other books by him, one of which looks at the likely demise of the Y Chromosome, thereby rendering us blokes redundant(A Future Without Men); and he posits some suggestions about why some women only bear sons, and some only daughters (I can't recall which book this is in). Finally, he looks at the DNA makeup of the British Isles (?and Ireland?), and comes to some conclusions based on DNA analysis about the predominance of Celtic genes not only in the Celtic countries, but also in England (book = Blood of the Isles).
I am sure you would enjoy reading his books - I found them very readable and darned exciting. You could have a look here http://www.oxfordancestors.com/ but an internet search for him brings up plenty of references. I think you will find an approachable way of learning about DNA and genetics through Sykes, because of the way he presents his material.
John
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by ritpetite , New Zealand, Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 10:55 (4852 days ago) @ jhopkins
Kia Ora to you too
Wow thank you for that explanation. Will try and get his books. Hope I can understand them.
Best Wishes
Rita
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by Roger Griffiths , Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 13:40 (4852 days ago) @ ritpetite
Sure does. I only wish everyone was on a DNA database. It would make family history a doddle. But then again I suppose it would be no fun if it was that easy. A couple of years ago a big exercise was undertaken to compare English DNA's with those of western seaboard of Europe from southern Denmark to Holland. 65% were compatible. This is despite large scale internal migration within UK in particularly 19th Century.
England = Angle Land = southern Denmark/Schleswig Holstein. As the Angles were a minority of the Anglo Saxons it would have been more accurate for England to be called New Saxony or something similar.
As far as FoD is concerned, mixture of Celts and Anglo Saxons. Different DNA.
Roger
Silures ~~ Early Voresters
by mrsbruso , Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 16:52 (4851 days ago) @ Roger Griffiths
Parhaps a moderator will be kind and paste the prior thread, but Slowhands discussed the possible enthnicity of the Forest people http://www.forum.forest-of-dean.net/index.php?id=3120
"Silures -- Early Voresters" 11 June 2006.
I knew reading all the old threads would come in handy sometime!
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by jhopkins , Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 22:36 (4851 days ago) @ ritpetite
Kia ora ano - you will have no trouble with them! If I can manage them I am sure you will too - see my reply to Llangrove (Cynthia). John (snowed under down here - literally).
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by Llangrove , Pennsylvania U.S.A., Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 19:43 (4851 days ago) @ jhopkins
John,
Thanks for your recent post! You reminded me that I bought, "Saxons, Vikings and Celts", probably three years ago. I put it aside for "winter reading", then with an accident and too many "dead people" on my mind, I forgot all about the book! I was about to order it (again) from Amazon, when it occured to me that the cover looked very familar. There it was on my book shelves! Another reason to love the people here and this wonderful site! Thanks!
Cynthia
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by ritpetite , New Zealand, Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 21:03 (4851 days ago) @ Llangrove
They say that Joseph of Arimathea was a Silure, see this site quite interesting:
http://www.biblesearchers.com/hebrewchurch/primitive/losttribesisrael1.shtml
Rita
Wish we could see into the past.
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by jhopkins , Tuesday, August 16, 2011, 22:33 (4851 days ago) @ Llangrove
Cynthia - I am glad to be an aide memoire! However, when you mentioned Saxons, Vikings and Celts, I got excited thinking Sykes must have written another book. However, it turns out to be Blood of the Isles with a different title for publishing in the United States and Canada.
All of his books are interesting, and worth reading, because of his writing skill and determination to reach a wider audience. Genetics floored me at school - Bishop Mendel and all those pea plants - but I was able to understand and be excited by Sykes' writing. Enjoy Saxons, Vikings and Celts. Including the curious tale of the so-called Neanderthal family in Wales - school teachers apparently used to take their students to meet them...
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by Roger Griffiths , Wednesday, August 17, 2011, 13:30 (4851 days ago) @ jhopkins
There were 5 or 6 Celtic tribes in Wales. The Silures were the tribe of south eastern Wales. The Romans were quite interested in the Silures, seeing a Mediterranean ancestry, particularly Basques of Spain. I don't think any satisfactory conclusion as been reached so far.
Roger
Does our DNA come from our Ancestors
by jhopkins , Wednesday, August 17, 2011, 23:33 (4850 days ago) @ Roger Griffiths
Brian Sykes' dna research suggested strong connections between British and Irish tribes and the peoples of the Iberian Peninsula, rather than with the tribes in places like La Tene and Hallstad etc further east in Europe (the so-called 'homeland' of the culture referred to as Celtic). If I recall correctly, his dna research made a particular connection with the Basque people.
Sykes suggests that the 'Celtic' tribes of Britain and Ireland had migrated up the coast of the Iberian Peninsula and crossed over from there (and there is a well known strong connection culturally and linguistically between the Bretons and the Welsh). In light of Sykes's research, it appears as though the Romans may have been correct in assuming a connection between the Basques and the Silures.
Y-DNA - Male Test used with genealogy
by admin , Forest of Dean, Thursday, August 18, 2011, 00:10 (4850 days ago) @ ritpetite
Y-DNA - Male Test
This is the DNA test used with genealogy as the Y-chromosome element of DNA passes from father to son basically unchanged. read more...
Y-DNA - Male Test used with genealogy: Sterry/Sterrey
by peteressex , Tuesday, November 22, 2011, 07:47 (4754 days ago) @ admin
I'm wondering how many other Forest families may have had success in tracing themselves back through the wonders of biology beyond where written records can help.
The Sterry/Sterrey family of Lydney (my paternal grandmother's line) had been unable to track back beyond a marriage at Minsterworth in the 1790s (Richard Sterry to Ann Toomey or similar) and subsequent movement from there via Awre to Lydney. But, through a project accessed via www.sterryworldwide.com, a living male Sterrey provided a DNA sample a few weeks ago which has turned out to prove that our line connects with the Sterrys of Longhope, thereby linking us to the marriage of a Richard Sterry (then spelt Stirry) there in 1686 and therefore to the putative birth of that progenitor around the early 1660s. This has been achieved despite the fact that the old Longhope registers are in a bit of a state where they survive at all, so that we still can't spell out the tree from the one Richard to the other.
With a spot of speculation, given the proximity of Longhope to Ruardean, we can now imagine ourselves connected to the Sterrys of Ruardean who go back to a marriage there in 1539 (and therefore a birth in say 1515) and are the oldest proven Sterry line in the world. As the order to keep parish registers only went forth in 1537, and early compliance was patchy, we would all be very lucky to prove ancestry older than that.
Without DNA, I would have been stuck at my gt-gt-gt-gt-grandfather's sudden manifestation as a bridegroom in Minsterworth a mere 218 years ago. Anybody had similar joy?
Y-DNA - Male Test used with genealogy: Sterry/Sterrey
by Jefff , West London, Middlesex, Tuesday, November 22, 2011, 14:13 (4754 days ago) @ peteressex
Hi Peter,
as you know I'm not in your line but this is very interesting to me from a scientific viewpoint, as it will be to my son currently studying biology at school.Please tell me if I'm prying into anything overly private and personal, thats not my intention, but please if possible and without too much graphic detail can you point us as to where the historical Sterry DNA sample was obtained. I presume it involves opening ancient graves, which personally I would have thought even with the family's permission might be difficult to achieve ?.
Y-DNA - Male Test used with genealogy: Sterry/Sterrey
by peteressex , Tuesday, November 22, 2011, 14:44 (4754 days ago) @ Jefff
Jefff, it's really quite easy at night with muffled equipment borrowed from an oil exploration company.
But seriously, the recent Sterrey DNA sample (from one still walking and talking in Lydney) matched samples from living Sterrys with more traditional proof of their descent from the Longhope progenitor.
The Ruardean link is only intelligent guesswork. However, judging by the amount of scaffolding round Ruardean Church when I was there in September, I reckon my lot have had their usual effect on a bastion of the establishment.
Y-DNA - Male Test used with genealogy: Hulin family
by Richard Hulan , Thursday, November 24, 2011, 19:49 (4751 days ago) @ admin
Replying specifically to this request: "If you have results of Y-DNA - Male Tests please send them to me as I shortly intend to add a DNA section to our website..."
I'm co-administrator of a small Y-DNA surname project for a Hulin family that was established in Virginia and North Carolina at least by the 1660s, and probably earlier. (It's hard to prove anything that early, as the surviving records of our southern colonies are spotty; and the spelling of this surname differs from one document to the next.) Anyway, some of us are beginning to have DNA tests, some of us match, and the consensus is growing that there is one pretty stable lineage, within haplogroup R1b, the defining SNPs (so far) being P312+ and Z196+. At the moment the ISOGG haplotree is calling this group R1b1a2a1a1b2* (but this terminology changes, as new SNPs are discovered, so it may not be valid when someone reads this post at a date later than November 2011). Here is a link to our project:
http://www.familytreedna.com/public/Hul_n_/default.aspx
The only British member of the family yet to be tested (Donald Hulin of Clevedon, Somerset) doesn't match our baseline (kit #195834 and similar results); but it seems possible that he actually has a direct paternal ancestor of the Scott family. If you look at the Y-DNA Results page in the project I have linked, Don is kit #195838. We would like to find some other male member(s) of the Forest of Dean Hulin family -- preferably not a very close relative of Don's -- who could be tested, as a check on that question. The company through which we are testing, Family Tree DNA, has a sale in progress (through Dec. 31, 2011) so it's currently less expensive than usual to be tested, if one does so through an FTDNA project such as ours. We recommend 37 marker tests.
If a "Forest of Dean Surnames" project is established by participants in this forum, and the testing is done at a company other than FTDNA, you may still access our public project results and see whether our baseline markers do, or don't, match those found among the Hulins from St. Briavels or Awre.