Near identical baptism records. Is this just a coincidence? (General)
In 1796, Coleford was a chapel of ease to All Saints, Newland. My ggreatgrandfathers sister Mary was baptised there in 1829. Remnants of the chapel of ease can still be seen. The 1872 church is a quite new building in a different part of Coleford. I can't remember now, I don't think Newland registers have double entries. Clearwell and Bream were originally chapels of ease. Clearwell has a new church (1830) and Bream was similar or a new church built(1813).
Added: Also Redbrook.